Why Are Ratings So High for Grey’s Anatomy?
Many fans, including myself, find it puzzling that the popular medical drama, Grey’s Anatomy, continues to achieve such high ratings, despite its numerous criticisms. A closer look at Reddit discussions provides insight into why this confusion persists.
As I dove into the first season, I was immediately taken aback by what appeared to be a casual portrayal of sexual harassment. Uncomfortable scenes filled with inappropriate behavior seemed to pass off as humor.
Further aggravating my viewing experience were the characters themselves, seemingly reduced to one-dimensional stereotypes – the goody two shoes, the sexist man, the sassy black woman, the overachieving Asian woman, and the goofy male clown.
MORE: Dr. Penelope “Penny” Blake on “Grey’s Anatomy” Is Hated Among Fans, But Why?
A disconcerting lack of realism also became apparent as I continued to watch the series. While other medical dramas I’ve loved touched upon the economic realities of healthcare and the challenges of health insurance, Grey’s Anatomy seemed to largely ignore these significant issues.
As I browsed through Reddit, I found I was not alone in my frustrations. Other viewers shared their disappointments over the death or departure of beloved characters. It appeared the series had lost some of its charm with the exits of prominent figures like George, Derek, Mark, Lexie, Burke, Izzie, Cristina, and most recently, Alex and Meredith.
One common grievance was the heavy focus on romantic relationships – it seemed characters were in a constant cycle of jumping from one relationship to another, leading to a web of confusion about who was truly in love with whom.
Discussion also emerged around the quality of acting in the series. Particularly, Ellen Pompeo’s performance as Meredith Grey was under scrutiny, with some viewers expressing that her acting felt uninspired and flat, as if she were simply going through the motions.
Many viewers, also questioned the portrayal of relationships in the series. The show seemed to link cheating with love, while trying to insert philosophical views and complex relationship dynamics. From my perspective, it seemed more like people were unable to control their impulses around colleagues.
Critics among the viewers, also raised concerns about the show’s representation of the medical profession. We noted instances of malpractice that slipped by without repercussions and pointed out that the doctors on the show seemed to be performing every task, even those typically assigned to nurses.
Yet, despite these concerns, Grey’s Anatomy continues to air, now in its 19th season and in March 2023 ABC confirmed that the series will return for its 20th season. While the high ratings suggest a large, dedicated audience, these voiced criticisms offer an important counterpoint. It seems the series has potential areas for improvement that could enhance its realism and depth, thereby possibly reducing viewer confusion and dissatisfaction.
