10 ‘One-Hit Wonders’ in the Acting World According to Fans

Actors Fans Appreciate Only in a Single Role.

Hollywood is home to a plethora of talented actors, many of whom have a host of blockbusters under their belts.

MORE: Worst James Bond Movies According to Fans

However, not every role played by these artists resonates with fans, and sometimes, even well-established actors are most beloved for a single, standout performance. According to a recent discussion on Reddit, several fans have identified these “one-hit wonders” of the acting world, with some surprising results of actors they generally aren’t fond of.

Mark Wahlberg, known for his tough-guy persona, received praise for his performance in “Boogie Nights.” One user noted that although Wahlberg’s off-screen persona may be off-putting, his role in this film was a perfect fit. However, they also mentioned that Wahlberg has since disowned the film due to its content not aligning with his personal beliefs.

Ryan Reynolds, another actor whose performances are often criticized for being too similar, was commended for his work in the space-horror movie “Life.” Despite Reynolds playing a limited role in the film, his performance was considered more tolerable compared to his usual comedic roles.

The multi-talented Tyler Perry, often known for his comedic Madea character, was lauded for his serious performance in the thriller “Gone Girl.” Tom Arnold, too, was recognized for his role in “True Lies,” a standout performance among his filmography.

Vin Diesel, famous for his “Fast and Furious” franchise, was applauded for his performance in “Riddick,” where fans thought he was best suited. Michelle Rodriguez, another “Fast and Furious” alumna, was praised for her role in the new “Dungeons and Dragons” movie, where her typical tough gal persona was fresh and engaging.

The Oscar-winning Jared Leto, often controversial for his method acting approach, received a nod for his role in “Requiem for a Dream.” Lastly, Tim Allen’s performance in “Galaxy Quest” was cherished by fans, who thought it was a departure from his usual roles.

Seann William Scott, known primarily for his role as the outrageous Stifler in the “American Pie” series, was commended for his more nuanced performance in “Role Models.” This shows how an actor often typecast in a certain kind of role can surprise audiences with a different character.

Jesse Eisenberg, often characterized by his quick-talking, neurotic roles. However, his portrayal of Mark Zuckerberg in “The Social Network” won over fans who otherwise find his on-screen mannerisms off-putting.

Megan Fox, frequently criticized for being typecast in “eye-candy” roles, was praised for her performance in “Jennifer’s Body.” In this role, she played a possessed high school girl, showing off her acting chops and adding depth to her filmography.

Gwyneth Paltrow, despite having a successful career with multiple acclaimed performances, was mentioned specifically for her role as Pepper Potts in the “Iron Man” and “Avengers” series. For this Reddit user, it seems that Paltrow’s portrayal of the reliable and resilient Pepper was a standout performance.

Lastly, Shia LeBeouf was lauded for his role in “Fury.” This war drama saw LeBeouf delivering a performance that left an impact on viewers, despite his controversial off-screen persona.